David Stukus, an associate professor of pediatrics with the allergy and immunology department at the Ohio-based Nationwide Children's Hospital. IgG is really a memory antibody, says Dr. Both IgG tests again claimed Agro is intolerant to these foods.īoth sets of lab results also showed Agro is "intolerant" of egg whites, all milks, wheat and gluten - all foods she eats regularly without issue. She also ate vegetable soup - containing barley, kidney beans and corn - without problem. Yet both tests suggested Agro is intolerant to flax. ![]() Yet both tests reported intolerances to foods she regularly consumed, with absolutely no adverse reactions.įor example, Agro had a smoothie, which included flax seeds, for breakfast daily. (Tyana Grundig/CBC)īefore taking the tests, Agro had tracked what she was eating. The tests offered by both Dynacare and Rocky Mountain Analytical require a requisition from a naturopathic doctor or licensed physician. The results from the Rocky Mountain Analytical test reported intolerances to 52 foods, while Dynacare reported 30 intolerances. LifeLabs' test is typically offered through naturopaths or other health outlets, however, while Dynacare's food intolerance test is advertised and promoted directly to the consumer in its clinics. To test the accuracy of these food sensitivity tests, Marketplace ran several different kinds on host Charlsie Agro, including drawing blood for the IgG tests offered by Dynacare and Rocky Mountain Analytical, which is owned by LifeLabs.īoth tests require a requisition from a naturopathic doctor or licensed physician. "If these tests result in the harm of a child, we really gotta think twice about whether or not these labs should be offering these," he said. One young patient of his developed a milk allergy after eliminating it from his diet when a food sensitivity test suggested he had a milk intolerance. Removing foods from your diet could also lead to development of a food allergy, especially in children, says Mack. By unnecessarily eliminating foods, he says he sees "kids that are coming in with nutritional deficiencies, with failure to grow very well." Interpreting the test otherwise is not only incorrect, but potentially hazardous to your health, Mack argues. Douglas Mack is a pediatric allergy, asthma and immunology specialist. "It should be used to track whether a patient actually is developing tolerance, not intolerance," he said.ĭr. IgG tests measure levels of an antibody known as Immunoglobulin G - or IgG, for short. Douglas Mack, a pediatric allergy, asthma and immunology specialist, argues the results of an IgG test are an indication that you had exposure to the foods - not an intolerance of them. Sensitivities or intolerances, on the other hand, are not related to the immune system and often take hours, if not days, to take effect - and are therefore very difficult to diagnose. An allergy is an immediate, immune response, and foods like nuts and seafood are often known to cause allergic responses that can be life-threatening. The reports being generated by the IgG test taken by Chapnick and countless others are being grossly misinterpreted, critics say.įood sensitivities are different from food allergies. ![]() Two of Canada's biggest labs, Dynacare and LifeLabs, promote and offer something known as IgG food tests at their labs, marketed as a way to test for food sensitivities.īut medical experts, including the Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology (CSACI), call IgG tests for food sensitivities "unvalidated," and more than two dozen organizations warn about the misuse of such tests. And with food sensitivity tests specifically ranging in cost from more than $100 to nearly $400, companies are cashing in on the craze. The value of the global food allergy and sensitivity industry is expected to hit a whopping $24.8 billion US by 2020. Friday on CBC TV or online.Ĭhapnick is not alone.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |